Who's Better for Me...(horoscope wise)?

Scorpio: 11/19/1987 Women :::::::: Libra 09/23/1982 Male and a Capricorn Male 1/1/1984...They both have Pro's and Con's. I am in love w\ Libra. I have a Love for Capricorn ( due to past ). Libra is easy going, positive , very "pleasing", he is good with my son that is nt biologically nt his, I just think that he quit me for is ex (inter insecurities) but has fallen on hard times on the way up.......... Capricorn .. aim to please, ( up to tom foolary), I believe he lies or add to make thing interesting, manipulator, and wants me to bow ( believes in He is the man, the Head and thats it). His wy is the right way...n he is a provider..but we dnt agree on his way of parenting my son( when we were together) What do you think,,,??