Long distance relationship delima. Please help!?

Okay, So I have been talking to a guy for about 3 years. We have our rough patches and don't always agree on stuff considering he lives in Pakistan and is Muslim and I live in the U.S. and I am Christain. I really truly love him with all of my heart and he promises he is moving here with me in two years once he is done with school. Which I pray and hope he is right, but here's the problem. Just recently I met a guy who lives 5 miles from my house and is really great and I am starting to like him a lot. and I am never a cheater and I haven't cheated, but the thing is I miss having someone here with me and me being able to touch and hold and kiss my significant other. so, I am afraid I can't wait two long years even though I want to deep down inside because I see my boyfriend as a life buddy, and then I see this new guy as just some new random guy that probally won't end up being a life buddy like I want. Please help me out here.